Mgr. Hovsep Kocharyan, Ph.D.

Mgr. Hovsep Kocharyan, Ph.D.

Post-Doctoral Legal Researcher & Member of CLAiR - Czech Law and Advanced Technologies Research Institute, UPOL

Palacky University Olomouc (Czech Republic)

Profile ID RP-003-9587 Joined 2026-04-15 18 articles
0Connections
4
Total Views
18
Total Publications
443
Publication Views

About me

Mgr. Hovsep Kocharyan, Ph.D., is a legal scholar affiliated with Palacký University Olomouc, where he specializes in International and European Union law, with a particular focus on EU digital law. His research explores some of the most pressing challenges at the intersection of technology and human rights, including the protection of the right to be forgotten, Internet access, informational self-determination, digital sovereignty, digital identity, and the digital integrity of the individual within the EU legal framework. Dr. Kocharyan is the author and co-author of numerous academic publications indexed in WoS and Scopus, as well as book chapters, research blogs, and other scholarly contributions addressing contemporary legal issues in the digital sphere. His academic work is enriched by international research experience across leading European institutions in the Netherlands, Oslo, Geneva, Zurich, and Brussels. Throughout his career, he has served both as a principal investigator and as a member of research teams in various grant-funded projects. He has actively participated in numerous local and international academic conferences, including the prestigious Computers, Privacy and Data Protection Conference 2023 in Brussels. Dr. Kocharyan is also a member of the Czech Law and Advanced Technologies Research Institute, where he contributes to interdisciplinary research on law and emerging technologies. In addition to his core expertise, his research interests extend to esports, bio- and nano-law, FinTech, crypto-law and regulation, and the evolving challenges of anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing (AML/CFT).

Articles(18)

Authors: Tanel Kerikmäe, Peeter Müürsepp, Henri Mart Pihl, Ondrej Hamuľák, Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.11590/abhps.2020.2.05

Volume8
Issue2
Pages73-92
Abstract

Artificial intelligence (AI) is developing rapidly. There are technologies available that fulfil several tasks better than humans can and even behave like humans to some extent. Thus, the situation prompts the question whether AI should be granted legal person- and/or agenthood? There have been similar situations in history where the legal status of slaves or indigenous peoples was discussed. Still, in those historical questions, the subjects under study were always natural persons, i.e., they were living beings belonging to the species Homo sapiens. We analyse the situation from moral-ethical and practical perspectives. The final conclusion is that the currently existing AIs are still so far removed from humans that there is simply no need to think seriously about legal person- or agenthood. Doing so would mean imposing obligations on the AI to follow. This, in turn, would mean that certain rights in relation to those obligations would have to be granted as well. By all evidence, this is something that humans are not ready to do yet and might never get that far.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan, Václav Stehlík, Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.2478/bjes-2022-0008

Volume12
Issue1
Pages159-185
Abstract

The article is devoted to the research of the problematic aspects and modern challenges of data protection in the digital age from the perspective of the digital integrity of the person. We believe that personal data cannot be effectively protected as components of digital integrity of the person in the context of regulation of a separate right to personal data protection, which, in its turn, acts more as a tool of market regulation rather than a classical fundamental right. We argue that the consideration of digital integrity as a new foundation for digital rights and as a new manifestation of the restrictive concept of human dignity may help increase the level of effective protection of the person in the digital sphere as well as properly cover the existing gaps in the protection of the digital rights of the person.

Authors: Hovsep Kocharyan, Lusine Vardanyan, Ondrej Hamuľák, Tanel Kerikmäe

DOI: 10.2478/iclr-2021-0015

Volume21
Issue2
Pages96-115
Abstract

This scientific paper is devoted to the critical analysis of the right to be forgotten after the entry into force of the GDPR, including the analysis of the existing case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (hereinafter – the CJEU) on the above right, as well as the legislative experience of the EU member States. The main research questions of this paper are as follows: Does the right to be forgotten effectively protects human privacy? What are the main shortcomings of the right to be forgotten in law enforcement practice? How can such shortcomings be corrected in order to improve the effectiveness and practicality of the right to be forgotten? The authors try to find reasonable solutions to the practical issues related to the realization of the right to be forgotten and offer their vision of improving the effectiveness of this right in the European legal practice.

Authors: Ondrej Hamuľák, Lilla Nóra Kiss, Tomáš Gábriš, Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.2478/iclr-2021-0006

Volume21
Issue1
Pages153-183
Abstract

The phenomenon of geo-blocking is one of the new challenges of the digital era. Geo-blocking is a modern form of discrimination that differentiates between consumers on the basis of their geographical location. The phenomenon ultimately affects the situation of the citizen concerned and may also constitute an obstacle to the single market. Digital time has put a number of issues to be resolved on the legislator’s table in recent years, one of which is the phenomenon of geo-blocking. Already in 2015, the European Commission led by Juncker (2014–2019) adopted the Digital Single Market (DSM) strategy, which marked the European Union’s (EU) path towards innovation by creating a new digital dimension of the Single Market. In order to achieve the DSM strategy and the digital objectives, a number of legislative acts have been put in place to address the elements of the DSM and exploit the benefits of technological modernisation. The geo-blocking phenomenon is presented in this study, partly in terms of practical aspects and partly with regard to the geo-blocking regulation. The Ursula von der Leyen-led Commission (2019–2024) identifies “a Europe fit for the digital age” among its six priorities. Among the priorities, the “promotion of a European way of life”, must be linked to the digital priorities, as our smart tools and our digital presence are becoming an integral part of our lives – and our common way of life – especially at this time of the COVID-19 pandemic. Innovation has also been accelerated by the current exceptional situation, the health emergency caused by COVID-19, forcing us to work remotely, remote contacts and the constant use of our smart tools. The realisation of digital well-being is therefore also an integral part of our lifestyle. In the intersection of digitalisation and development and the promotion of a common European way of life, we can find a single market in which we can experience a significant aspect of our European way of life – the free movements and cross-border transactions – even through our online presence. The internal market is the dimension for the proper functioning of which the Union institutions can adopt a legislative act. In addition, measures taken to remove barriers and remove obstacles are essential for the functioning of the internal market. Joint action against geo-blocking as an internal market barrier will also play a role in creating digital prosperity by promoting the proper functioning of the internal market by promoting e-commerce and electronic content access. The aim of the study on the one hand is to present issues related to geo-blocking in a brief and descriptive manner from the perspective of the social, economic and legal environment linked to the internal market. On the other hand, the study briefly presents the legal environment of geo-blocking in the USA, Russia, China and Japan.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan, Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.2478/eustu-2022-0004

Volume9
Issue1
Pages91-109
Abstract

At the end of 2020, the European Commission published a new European data strategy, which aims to create a new legal framework to promote the development of a single European data market. In the scope of the new strategy the European Commission has already proposed the Data Governance Act proposal (hereinafter – the “DGA”), which aims to strengthen the mechanism to facilitate data exchange. The proposal of the new legislative act has raised the question about the right balance between it and the existing EU legislative acts, which were adopted in the key of personal data protection, especially with the General Data Protection Regulation (hereinafter – the “GDPR”). We argue that there are a number of inconsistencies between the DGA proposal and the GDPR that may prevent the full implementation of mechanisms that allow achieving the EU’s intended goals in this field within the framework of the new European strategy. The interaction of the DGA with the GDPR is characterized by conflict of laws and legal uncertainty, which can jeopardize the achievement of the objectives of the DGA itself and can reduce the level of personal data protection in the EU, compared to the GDPR. Besides, the examination of the relevant case-law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (hereinafter – the “CJEU” or the “Court”) regarding the implementation of the GDPR identifies approaches that prevent the opening of data exchange as the DGA proposal requires.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan, Hovsep Kocharyan, Ondrej Hamulák, Matúš Mesarčík, Tanel Kerikmäe, Tea Kookmaa

DOI: 10.5817/mujlt2023-1-3

Volume17
Issue1
Pages87-109
Abstract

The dynamic development of digital and informational technologies raises the issue of proper and effective protection of human privacy, which, in turn, is gradually turning from a real fundamental right into a kind of illusion. Just a piece of information about an individual distributed on the Internet may leave its negative and often indelible mark on the life and reputation of the addressee of such information, regardless of the legality and reliability of such information. And even if such information is subsequently recognized as false and/or vicious and even removed from public access, the addressee of the information will still be associated with such information in the social consciousness. In this regard, each person is at risk on the Internet, where anyone can potentially become the victim of a single publication or a post of an Internet user. In this context the emergence of the phenomenon of the right to be forgotten in European legal reality may be considered as a step forward in the question of human privacy protection in the digital age. However, this right is not without drawbacks. The most significant of these drawbacks will be analyzed in this paper, such as the practical difficulties of thoroughly exercising this right and the difficulties posed by new technological developments.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan, Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.2478/eustu-2022-0016

Volume9
Issue2
Pages110-132
Abstract

This article is devoted to determining the role and place of the EU in the international information space, as well as identifying problematic aspects and existing challenges that the EU faces in implementing its digital strategy in the field of data governance and protection. In the context of the growing influence of such key political figures as, for example, the USA and China, which have dominant influence on the digital economy, the issue of proper ensuring the digital sovereignty of the EU in the field of global data governance comes to the fore. This is due to the fact that it is the digital sovereignty that should guarantee the strategic autonomy of the EU in the digital world in the context of the EU’s increasing dependence on foreign technologies and services and a shortage of investments in the digital sector. In this research, the authors focus on the need to develop and use a model of multilateral participation in the field of data governance and protection in the digital world, which, in turn, implies prevention of weakening the role of the state in regulating the digital market, since it is the states (including the EU) that are the primary guarantors of human rights protection in the digital world.

Authors: Tomáš Gábriš, Ondrej Hamuľák, Hovsep Kocharyan, Pablo Martínez Ramil

DOI: 10.2478/bjes-2024-0022

Volume14
Issue2
Pages190-216
Abstract

The growing popularity and expansion of esports have prompted an academic and legal debate, where its classification as either a sport or a form of entertainment remains unclear. This article explores the dual nature of esports, providing an overview of the legal and regulatory challenges it presents. It opens the discussion by addressing the space occupied by esports, distinguishing it from the traditional understanding of analogue sports while introducing the role of various stakeholders. The article then delves into the legal discussion taking place at the EU level, exploring also how the national legal reality of some Member States approach esports. The study highlights the urgency of finding a balanced approach that recognises esports as a hybrid entity, necessitating a regulatory model that draws from both sports law and entertainment law. Furthermore, the article complements the analysis by addressing emerging normative systems within esports, including autonomous governance structures and the potential need for state intervention to address issues such as doping, match-fixing, and the protection of minors. By analysing the existing legal frameworks in non-EU countries, particularly in Asia and North America, the authors suggest that esports needs to be approached as a new type of sport—a perspective that should be reflected in future EU regulations.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan, Ondrej Hamuľák, Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.2478/eustu-2024-0005

Volume11
Issue1
Pages105-121
Abstract

Informational self-determination is a crucial legal principle that grants individuals greater control over their digital existence. This paper examines the complexities of digital identity and the legal challenges it presents. Digital identity blends objective elements, such as official documentation, with subjective aspects like personal and cultural affiliations. The increasing overlap between physical and digital identities raises legal and ethical concerns regarding identity protection, consent, and anonymity. The fragmentation of digital identity, risks of identity theft, and the expansion of digital profiling highlight the need for stronger legal mechanisms. While existing laws like the GDPR offer some protection, a broader legal framework is required to recognise identity as a fundamental right. The right to be forgotten and control over one’s digital self-representation are essential for personal autonomy. The study underscores how digital identity is increasingly shaped by third parties, leading to vulnerabilities that threaten fundamental rights. Expanding current privacy laws through the doctrine of informational self-determination is crucial for safeguarding identity in the evolving technological landscape.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan, Hovsep Kocharyan, Ondrej Hamuľák, Tanel Kerikmäe

DOI: 10.1007/978-3-031-27312-4_14

Volume1
Issue1
Pages219-234
Abstract

In accordance with the principles of international law, each state has the exclusive authority to enact laws on its territory. However, digital transformation, in particular the dissemination of data, threatens the traditional foundations of sovereignty and jurisdiction. At the same time, in recent years, the EU has increasingly turned to the need to introduce the idea of digital sovereignty into its agenda. In this chapter, researchers analyse EU legislation, in particular GDPR (Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data, and repealing Directive 95/46/EC (General Data Protection Regulation) (Text with EEA relevance). Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32016R0679) and DSA, as well as EU law enforcement practice, in order to identify the legal mechanisms by which the EU is trying to realize its idea of digital sovereignty. Special attention is paid to the mechanisms of localization and extraterritoriality. The researchers conclude that EU data protection laws distinguish between the establishment of an extraterritorial effect and the localization of data.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan, Ondrej Hamuľák, Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.1016/j.iot.2024.101279

Volume27
Issue101279
Pages101279
Abstract

This paper discusses the controversial and evolving nature of the right to personal integrity in the context of modern legal discourse, with a specific focus on its intersection with bodily boundaries and bio- and digital technologies. It points out that the traditional understanding of this right may no longer be sufficient to protect individuals, especially given the advancements in digital technologies, the Internet of bodies (IoB), as well as the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. This research highlights the ongoing debate and legal complexities surrounding the right to personal integrity and personal autonomy, especially in the face of technological advancements, and suggests the need for a broader perspective to safeguard human dignity and physicality, both in the physical and digital domains. For these purposes, the evolving legal landscape is explored, with reference to the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) and the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). We believe that the classic concept of the right to personal integrity no longer ensures the security of the individual, and in order to achieve this goal, it is necessary to expand its scope taking into account the human dignity, especially in the context of the continuous progress of bio- and digital technologies.

Authors: Hovsep Kocharyan, Ondrej Hamuľák, Lusine Vardanyan

DOI: 10.2478/iclr-2022-0017

Volume22
Issue2
Pages105-120
Abstract

The protection of human privacy is one of the most disputable topics of European human rights law. That is why the judicial practice of the European Supranational Courts is rich in numerous decisions in this area, since human privacy is one of the most violated human rights, especially in the context of the development of digital technologies. Trying to find protection of their rights through institutional mechanisms of human rights (in particular, through the CJEU and the ECtHR), the applicant often finds himself/herself in a more difficult position: he/she becomes even more an object of public discussion. This phenomenon is especially vividly illustrated by the judicial practice of the European Supranational Courts in the field of protection of the right to be forgotten, which will be paid attention to in this research. At the same time, some suggestions will also be put forward to strengthen the effectiveness of protecting the confidentiality of applicants in the judicial decisions of the Courts.

Authors: Hovsep Kocharyan, Ondrej Hamuľák, Lusine Vardanyan

DOI: 10.2478/iclr-2024-0020

Volume24
Issue2
Pages106-123
Abstract

Nowadays Internet technologies are developing so much that they cover new social relations. Human life is undergoing rapid digitalisation, which inevitably leaves an imprint on the protection of fundamental rights. Political life is no exception either. Today the legal experience shows that the European states are already offering various effective mechanisms and solutions to strengthen their democratic principles, which are based precisely on Internet technologies, in which the concept of e-democracy (“electronic democracy”) is increasingly becoming an urgent topic of research. In this research, the authors will analyse on how the Internet access can ensure a dialogue between citizens and the government, as well as strengthen the EU’s democratic principles in the digital world. Moreover, the authors will also focus on the law enforcement experience of different European states in order to bring out their positive aspects that can become effective guidelines for building an appropriate mechanism for the participation of EU citizens in political life through Internet technologies.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan, Hovsep Kocharyan, Ondrej Hamuľák, Tomáš Gábriš, Pablo Martínez-Ramil

DOI: 10.1080/17579961.2026.2633686

Volume1
Issue1
Pages1-45
Abstract

Esports has become an important phenomenon of the digital age. Despite the rapid development of the esports industry, its legal regulation involves numerous issues. One of the key issues is the monopoly position of video game IP rightsholders who have exclusive rights to their products, which in turn limits the development of independent esports disciplines. This article analyses the factors that contribute to monopolisation in esports; it considers legal and economic models of combating monopoly, and it develops recommendations for improving legislative regulation of this area. It also analyses practical examples, suggests new approaches to optimising legal regulation for esports in EU law, and examines ways to achieve a balance between protecting the rights of video game rightsholders and players (esportspeople) on one side, and the freedom to develop independent esports disciplines on the other.

Authors: Kätlin Joala, Tanel Kerikmäe, Ondrej Hamuľák, Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.2478/eustu-2023-0014

Volume10
Issue2
Pages98-123
Abstract

This paper examines the origins and limitations of EU medical device law. The main questions asked are whether EU medical device law defines the concept of medical purpose for software, whether the concept of medical purpose is understood as a medical service defined by national law, and whether it requires the involvement of medical professionals as users. Particular attention is paid to the aspect of Recital 8 of the Regulation (EU) 2017/745 on medical devices (MDR), alongside the general internal provisions of EU law and its sector-specific subsidiarity provisions. In practice, Member States have taken different legal approaches to address DTx-related challenges, creating legal uncertainty within the EU as to which DTx should be defined as a medical device.

Authors: Lusine Vardanyan; Hovsep Kocharyan

DOI: 10.14658/pupj-JELT-2022-1-7

Volume4
Issue1
Pages105-120
Abstract

This paper is devoted to the analysis of the right to data protection as an integral part of personality rights in the context of property relations. Despite the fact that this right is commonly not considered from the point of view of property rights, the authors tend to believe that such a confrontation is increasingly becoming a fiction: the recognition of this right as an independent fundamental right in EU law does not exclude the possibility of its consideration in the context of property relations, since it is not a classical fundamental right and has a “market basis”. In its turn, the case law of the ECtHR reflects the concept of personality rights in the scope of the article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (hereinafter – “ECHR”) and this concept developed assumes an approach to property rights as an integral part of personality. In this framework, if the right to the protection of personal data is considered in the context of article 8 of the ECHR it may imply ownership of personal data.

The Global Reach of the right to be forgotten through the Lenses of the Court of Justice of the European Union 2021

Authors: Hamulak, Ondrej; Vardanyan, Lusine; Kocharyan, Hovsep

Volume12
Issue1
Pages196-211
Abstract

The paper is devoted to the analysis of the territorial scope of the application of the right to be forgotten, taking into account the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (hereinafter – “CJEU”), in particular, the case of Google v. Commission Nationale de l’Informatiqueet des Libertés (CNIL). Despite the prevailing view that in the Google v. CNIL case the CJEU limits the territorial scope of the right to be forgotten, the authors nevertheless tend to believe that the detailed analysis of the Court’s reasoning leads to the opposite conclusion. According to the authors, in this judgment the CJEU does not explicitly restrict the territorial scope of the right to be forgotten, and lays the foundation for the implementation and further development of the global application of this right, which is confirmed in subsequent case law, in particular in the case of Glawischnig-Piesczek v. Facebook Ireland Limited.

Authors: Hamuľák, Ondrej; Vardanyan, Lusine; Kocharyan, Hovsep

DOI: 10.18778/0208-6069.113.07

Volume113
Issue1
Pages105-136
Abstract

This article examines the evolving relationship between the human body and digital data, particularly in light of technological advancements that blur the distinction between physical and digital identities. The research explores the implications of this transformation for legal frameworks, questioning whether current data protection laws sufficiently safeguard personal integrity and identity in the digital age. This study emphasises the limitations of existing regulations, which primarily focus on personal data rather than the broader concept of individual identity. A central argument is that the right to informational self-determination discussed in the scientific literature and recognized in German legal practice should play a critical role in ensuring autonomy and personal identity protection. The discussion also highlights the necessity of developing more effective legal mechanisms to safeguard digital identities against technological vulnerabilities, unauthorised profiling, and market driven commodification of personal data. This study ultimately calls for a reconsideration of legal concepts such as bodily integrity, informational self-determination, and digital sovereignty, advocating for a more comprehensive legal approach to the protection of individuals in the digital sphere. This document argues that the existing legal framework inadequately protects new forms of identity in the digital environment, especially with regard to information self-determination and digital embodiment. By exploring the changing boundaries of the human body in technological and digital contexts, this article aims to promote clearer recognition of digital identity rights within legal systems.

No matching articles

Try another word from the title, author or DOI.

Brief Bio

Mgr. Hovsep Kocharyan, Ph.D., is a legal scholar affiliated with Palacký University Olomouc, where he specializes in International and European Union law, with a particular focus on EU digital law. His research explores some of the most pressing challenges at the intersection of technology and human rights, including the protection of the right to be forgotten, Internet access, informational self-determination, digital sovereignty, digital identity, and the digital integrity of the individual within the EU legal framework. Dr. Kocharyan is the author and co-author of numerous academic publications indexed in WoS and Scopus, as well as book chapters, research blogs, and other scholarly contributions addressing contemporary legal issues in the digital sphere. His academic work is enriched by international research experience across leading European institutions in the Netherlands, Oslo, Geneva, Zurich, and Brussels. Throughout his career, he has served both as a principal investigator and as a member of research teams in various grant-funded projects. He has actively participated in numerous local and international academic conferences, including the prestigious Computers, Privacy and Data Protection Conference 2023 in Brussels. Dr. Kocharyan is also a member of the Czech Law and Advanced Technologies Research Institute, where he contributes to interdisciplinary research on law and emerging technologies. In addition to his core expertise, his research interests extend to esports, bio- and nano-law, FinTech, crypto-law and regulation, and the evolving challenges of anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing (AML/CFT).

Affiliations

Nothing added yet.

Education

Nothing added yet.

Honors & Awards

Nothing added yet.

Society Memberships

Nothing added yet.

Expertise

Nothing added yet.

Specialty

Nothing added yet.

Suggested researchers

EE
Ehab Elsaih
Department of Prosthodontics, College of Dentistry, The Islamic University in Najaf, Najaf, Iraq.
20 publications
Dr. Supriya Subramani
Materials Science & Condensed Matter Physics
36 publications
SM
Shushruta Mohanty
15 publications
SS
Sankappa Sinhasan
AIIMS, Guwahati
27 publications
Mohamed Mesregah MD
Menoufia University Faculty of Medicine
79 publications
AK
Ashish Kamboj
Government Dental Centre, , India
21 publications
TJ
Tanim Jabid Hossain
University of Chittagong
27 publications
SY
Sankalp Yadav
Shri Madan Lal Khurana Chest Clinic, New Delhi, India
34 publications
Dr. Dukre Tushar Pradip
College of Pharmaceutical Sciences, PIMS (DU), Loni.
34 publications
AK
ANANDRAJ K C
Madurai Kamaraj University
16 publications
BHARANIDHARAN G
THE NEW COLLEGE, CHENNAI
17 publications
Akram Abu-Okail
Department of Clinical Pathology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt
16 publications

Following

Nobody here yet.

Followers

Nobody here yet.

18 Publications

The Global Reach of the right to be forgotten through the Lenses of the Court of Justice of the European Union

Authors: Hamulak, Ondrej; Vardanyan, Lusine; Kocharyan, Hovsep

Published in 2021