The Silent Consensus: Epistemic Injustice and the Gatekeepers of Artistic Truth
This paper examines the crisis of institutional trust in contemporary art authentication by analyzing the structural closures of monopoly archives, using the Kurt Schwitters Archive scandal as a diagnostic flashpoint. Drawing upon Miranda Fricker’s framework of epistemic injustice, the study demonstrates how elite art institutions perpetrate testimonial and hermeneutical injustice to systematically discredit independent material forensics and monopolize the conceptual criteria of artistic truth. This institutional pathology is shown to be driven by an internal "sociology of expert fear," wherein archive committees weaponize silence and prioritize the mitigation of reputational and financial risk over empirical verifiability. Far from operating in isolation, this monopoly is actively sustained by a financialized market infrastructure—including major auction houses and mega-galleries—that values absolute, binary institutional decrees to de-risk transactions and maintain artificial market scarcity, thereby enforcing a complicit "silent consensus." Crucially, this paper argues that these practices transcend academic grievances and constitute actionable legal wrongs under tort law, specifically crossing the thresholds of professional negligence and commercial disparagement through arbitrary, unchallengeable mechanisms such as the stigmatizing, reminiscent Judenkartei, Findbuch registration. Ultimately, the paper contends that while tort litigation provides a necessary reactive shield, resolving this systemic rot demands a paradigm shift away from rigid epistemic feudalism. It advocates for the realization of an "epistemic democracy" via polycentric, open-source models of provenance and decentralized technological verification—such as blockchain ledgers and peer-to- peer scholarly repositories—thereby returning the study of cultural heritage to a transparent, falsifiable science.